Hiring at executive level is one of the most consequential decisions you’ll make as a leader.
A single appointment can accelerate growth, strengthen culture and shape your company’s trajectory for years to come. But, if not fully considered, it can also potentially stall momentum, or worse set your strategy back, if made with haste or without absolute clarity.
When you’re considering your next key hire, I’d recommend taking a step back and spending a moment to ask yourself these five essential questions.
Your answers may change the way you think about your next hire entirely.
- What is it that I’m actually trying to solve?
Every hire should start with a clearly defined problem or opportunity, not a job title.
Occasionally, I hear, “We need a new COO” or “We need to get a Sales Director from one of our competitors,” without a definitive and compelling why statement.
Perhaps ask yourself ‘what gap or challenge is this person meant to address?’.
Is it to scale operations? Or to bring some discipline to the chaos? Reigning innovation perhaps? Or strengthening culture after a fraught period of rapid growth?
When you define the real problem to be addressed, you stop hiring based on familiarity or CV ‘comfort’ and start hiring based on strategic need. The most successful placements happen when the “why” behind the role is crystal clear.
- What’s the opportunity that we are truly offering here?
The best talent has choices and they probably won’t move purely for a title or salary. They most likely move for perceived opportunity.
Before you engage candidates, perhaps ask ‘what is exciting, unique and/or meaningful about this role, and how does it contribute to the company’s wider strategy and future vision?’.
Top executives want to know what they can build, transform or lead. If you’re unable to articulate the opportunity in a way that inspires you, it probably won’t inspire them either.
- How will this person influence our culture (and vice versa)?
Skills and experience matter, but culture fit and leadership style often determine commercial success.
Ask yourself ‘how will this person change the tone and tempo of my team?’.
Will they elevate the culture or disrupt it? Do their values align with how decisions get made here, or will they challenge norms in a way that’s actually healthy and long overdue?
At executive level, you’re hiring not only for capability, but for chemistry. Culture alignment isn’t simply about ‘more of the same’, but instead it’s arguably more about shared principles and complementary strengths.
- Have I looked internally before going to market?
In the rush to ‘find the best’, many leaders may overlook the talent sittng right in front of them.
Before launching an external search, perhaps ask, ‘do we already have someone who could grow into this role with the right support?’.
Promoting from within sends a powerful signal about opportunity, fairness and trust. It strengthens loyalty and preserves knowledge.
Even if you ultimately hire externally, exploring internal options forces clarity about what truly requires an outside perspective versus what could be solved through development and empowerment.
- What’s the real cost of getting this all wrong?
A mis-hire at the executive level doesn’t just cost money, it can cost momentum, credibility and time (amongst other things).
Maybe consider, ‘if this hire doesn’t work out, what’s at risk?’. Is it investor confidence? Team morale? Strategic execution?
Understanding the potential cost of failure can help you to calibrate your process; slowing down where diligence matters, involving the right stakeholders and partnering with advisors who know how to see beyond the CV.
In summary…
Intentional hiring IS strategic leadership.
The best leaders I’ve met during my career deem recruiting for key appointments as one of their most strategic acts, not an administrative task.
Before your next process, I implore you to dedicate good time to ask yourself and to honestly answer these few key questions.
Because in leadership hiring, clarity isn’t a luxury. It’s the difference between adding a name to your org chart and adding lasting value to your business.
Give me a call on 07835 123105 or drop me a line at kelly@kmnconsult.co.uk to let me know what you think about this topic and how I can support your search requirements.
KMN Consult specialise in ensuring you have the right people delivering the right results for your business; supporting leaders within the construction industry to build the right teams for the future.
If you’d like to learn more about my approach, or share your views on this topic, please reach out on 07835 123105 or kelly@kmnconsult.co.uk.