It’s likely you’ve hired a senior leader for your current or previous business through an executive search firm, so you’ll know the standard sequence of events: briefing, longlist, shortlist, interviews…offer. Done.

 

On paper, it looks pretty simple and clear; a direct path through the pre-defined steps. Easy, right?

 

In reality, though, the later stages in particular are often far more complex; a non-linear process driven by human emotions, thoughts and feelings. Much discussion, scenario exploration and career/life impact predictions are under consideration which can take a significant volume of psychological bandwidth.

 

Much of this goes unseen by the client. That’s essentially why I’m here and I do what I do.

 

A good search could be likened like a swan; smooth and graceful above the waterline, whilst underneath the legs are paddling hard to ensure things are moving towards the destination.

 

This often describes the quiet stretch between shortlist and offer. The invisible process from the middle of the funnel where 90% of the real (and more tricky) work happens.

 

Managing Human Variables

Once the shortlist is agreed, I’m no longer sourcing candidates, but effectively aligning human lives.

 

This is where motivations, timing and private conversations start to matter most. For example, one finalist’s partner might be uncertain about relocating, another might be juggling competing offers, plus numerous other variables. All of which needs exploring in depth behind the scenes.

 

As the headhunter, the role is to sense and understand hesitation before it manifests into withdrawal; to keep momentum alive without pushing too hard.

It’s arguably equal parts diplomacy, empathy and intuition; the majority of which would never be documented in a client report (as these are the background journey notes, not the clear outcome points that the client ultimately wants and deserves).

 

Protecting the Client Brand

Each interaction a candidate has during a search shapes how they perceive your company, so I try to invest a significant amount of time ‘backstage’ coaching candidates ahead of interview to help them understand the business context, the stakeholders and the culture they’re heading into.

 

Managing feedback is also key (ie what to share, when and how). A ‘wrong’ comment, delayed response or deviation from predefined process can potentially change a candidate’s perception of your organisation.

So, a good search partner isn’t just recruiting, but simultaneously (albeit quietly) protecting your reputation in the market.

 

Calibrating the Candidate ‘Fit’

‘Fit’ isn’t found on a CV. It’s revealed in tone, curiosity and how someone behaves when the process doesn’t go entirely perfectly.

That’s why I try to test for ‘Fit’ in subtle ways, such as follow-up conversations, informal chats, even how candidates handle silence.

 

By the time a finalist is recommended, I like to think that I’ve seen how they show up when the spotlight isn’t necessarily on, as such.

 

This is where the real confidence comes from for me.

 

Difficult Conversations

There can only be one successful candidate for each search process, so the flipside to this highly positive conversation are the many more tough ones. Informing good people that they didn’t land the role is delicate.

 

Each unsuccessful candidate would have also invested a considerable amount of time, energy and emotion in the journey and would have given it their best shot. Receiving a call of declination isn’t the desired outcome.

 

It’s essential that the feedback is clear/honest (to help moving forward), delivered with respect (to support with confidence) and to maintain the trust so you can work together on any specific areas referenced, with the objective to nail the next opportunity for the candidate.

 

Negotiating Without Negotiating

By the time we get to the offer, most of the negotiation has already happened…invisibly.

 

We’ve mapped motivations, deal-breakers, expectations and aspirations, so when an offer is presented it’s not a poker game. It’s alignment. The real art lies in pacing the close, creating space for both sides to feel understood and valued.

It’s less about winning and more about building a foundation that lasts for all.

 

The Quiet Margin of Error

Some of the most effective work done is in preventing bad decisions.

For example, the candidate who looked perfect on paper but raised one or two subtle red flags along the way that could lead to a last-minute change of heart that could turn into a costly retraction.

 

You never see those moments because I handle them (quietly).

 

The Unseen ‘Glue’

When a client tells me, “That search felt easy”, or similar, I take that as a significant win!

 

If it looked somehow effortless, it’s because most of the calories and tricky work happened out of sight (in audition and rehearsal phases) whilst keeping everything on course.

 

And all this ‘behind the curtain’ work is essentially what clients are investing in to a certain extent.

 

I liken myself to the translucent glue that keeps the process together, the needed-but-hard conversations on track and the momentum always moving forward towards the agreed end goal and timelines.

 

As a proven, trusted strategic partner to the building materials and manufacturing sectors, much of my best quality search work is mostly invisible to the client.

 

That’s why it works!

 

Give me a call on 07835 123105 or drop me a line at kelly@kmnconsult.co.uk to let me know how I can support your search requirements.

 

KMN Consult specialise in ensuring you have the right people delivering the right results for your business; supporting leaders within the construction industry to build the right teams for the future.

If you’d like to learn more about my approach, or share your views on this topic, please reach out on 07835 123105 or kelly@kmnconsult.co.uk.